National Archives reveal Hong Kong-to-NI ‘spoof’

Posted by Anton Murray Consulting on 6 Jul, 2015

A suggestion to move the population of Hong Kong to Northern Ireland sparked a flurry of correspondence in Whitehall in 1983, newly released documents show.

The bizarre plan was revealed in files published by the National Archives.

The novel idea came from a lecturer who warned that the British colony’s 5.5 million inhabitants would need a home when it was returned to China in 1997.

It sparked some debate among officials, with one saying there were “real advantages” in taking it seriously.

‘City state’

Prof Christie Davies, an expert in the sociology of morality, censorship and humour at the University of Reading, suggested a new “city state” could be created in Magilligan, between Coleraine and Londonderry.

The move could revitalise the stagnant Northern Ireland economy, he said.

When details of his idea first appeared in the Belfast News Letter in October 1983, they caught the eye of George Fergusson, a junior official in the Northern Ireland Office.

He sent a memorandum to David Snoxell, a colleague in the Republic of Ireland Department of the Foreign Office, saying: “At this stage we see real advantages in taking the proposal seriously.”

Among the benefits, he suggested, was that it would help convince the unionist population that the government in Westminster was truly committed to retaining Northern Ireland in the UK.

Mr Snoxell’s reply suggested the conversation was not entirely serious.

“My initial reaction… is that the proposal could be useful to the extent that the arrival of 5.5 million Chinese in Northern Ireland may induce the indigenous peoples to forsake their homeland for a future elsewhere,” he wrote.

“We should not underestimate the danger of this taking the form of a mass exodus of boat refugees in the direction of South East Asia.”

‘Mind-boggling’ plan

A second Foreign Office official commented: “My mind will be boggling for the rest of the day.”

But Mr Snoxell, now retired, revealed the exchange “was a spoof between colleagues who had a sense of humour”.

“You can see it wasn’t intended seriously,” he said.

“Sadly, it’s impossible to make jokes like this any more, the Diplomatic Service has lost its sense of humour.

“I think that’s a shame because it’s through humour that you build relationships, with other departments, with other diplomats at home and abroad.”

Other archives in the National Archives release reveal:

  • Alarm among officials over a visit by Greek culture minister Melina Mercouri, who was determined to secure the return of the Elgin Marbles from the British Museum
  • Fury at the Foreign Office after Prime Minister Margaret Thatcher insisted on placating the Saudi royal family who had complained about a BBC report that Iranian pilgrims to Mecca had been mistreated and imprisoned by Saudi authorities.


Latest market insights

Why nuance matters in ESG investing

› Read more

Fed issues warning to banks over crypto-assets

› Read more

Asset managers urged to adopt uniform ESG standards

› Read more

Greenwashing concerns dampen ESG enthusiasm

› Read more

Asset managers urged to adopt uniform ESG standards

› Read more

Twitter feed

This is an exceptional Unit Pricing Analyst position, working for a highly-regarded super fund based in Melbourne on an initial 6-month contract:

Why nuance matters in ESG investing:

Our client is a leading Australian financial institution seeking an experienced and knowledgeable Treasury Operations candidate to join and lead their small Treasury Ops team:

Our client is a leading fund that invests directly and indirectly in all major asset classes. They are seeking candidates with performance analytics experience for a contract role in Melbourne:

Sign up to our newsletter

Sign up to our newsletter

"*" indicates required fields

By subscribing to our newsletter I agree to the collection, use and disclosure of my personal information in accordance with our Privacy Policy