
Market Commentary
Grow, Recreo show admin insourcing is a high-wire act
Investment Magazine
Grow Inc is dead; long-live Grow, An MUFG Business®, or whichever formulation its new owner chooses, if it chooses one. In its short, troubled life it generated more than its fair share of headlines. In death, it illustrates a problem the industry will continue to deal with. To recap: the ACCC greenlit MUFG’s takeover of Grow because Grow was not/would not have been an effective and vigorous competitor due to its financial, operational and viability challenges and because MUFG would have continued to face competition from established businesses like Apex, SS&C and Bravura, all of which have fancy cloud-based platforms to rival MUFG’s aging aaspire. But another reason the ACCC was willing to approve MUFG’s takeover of Grow was because it believed that the ability of super funds to insource their administration arrangements provided enough competitive tension to keep MUFG on its toes.
That represents a significant change from the ACCC’s 2016 decision on the NSW Government-owned Pillar, when it said that funds that outsourced their administration services were unlikely to switch to insourcing on the basis that it would be “too costly and difficult”. The deal did not proceed, and Pillar was later acquired by Mercer. Of course, a lot has changed in the last decade. Many funds have achieved significant scale and are able to spread their costs across a wider member base, making it possible to undertake that “costly” part of the administration insourcing process, like Aware Super did with its Project Catalyst, rumoured to have cost around $300 million. But what the ACCC describes as “self-supply” hasn’t gotten a whole lot easier.
The rest of this article can be found at investmentmagazine.com.au.
Latest market insights
X feed